I have been in a lot of meetings over the past several years regarding the impasse in the United Methodist Church over human sexuality. I have always believed in the unity of the church and fought for it. I also realized that we were doing more harm by not figuring out some sort of space in the church over this issue…whether that be separation or even a split. There are people on both sides of this debate who feel they cannot remain in the United Methodist Church. The recent Protocol for Reconciliation and Grace Through Separation would provide a framework for those who feel they cannot remain in the United Methodist Church over this issue by birthing new denominations of Methodism. I lament the separation and the negative impact it will have on our mission, but we need to get to a place where we can focus on the central reason we exist as the church.
The Preamble of the United Methodist Church’s Constitution reads, “The church is a community of all true believers under the Lordship of Christ. It is the redeemed and redeeming fellowship in which the Word of God is preached by persons divinely called, and the sacraments are duly administered according to Christ’s own appointment. Under the discipline of the Holy Spirit the church seeks to provide for the maintenance of worship, the edification of believers, and the redemption of the world. The church of Jesus Christ exists in and for the world, and its very dividedness is a hindrance to its mission in that world.”
Over the past year, I have been in conversation with some African Bishops in the United Methodist Church. A few weeks ago, Bishop John Yambasu (Sierra Leone) sent me the following email, which he gave me permission to share:
“At this time in our long and confusing journey, I believe continued dialogue is a major step in attaining understanding and moving forward to a peaceful way of resolving our current unresolved debate on human sexuality. And I thank you so much for sharing your perspectives on the future of the UMC. For us in Africa and the Central Conferences, we believe the earlier we get this debate behind us the better for the work of mission that God has called us to. Each day, millions of people around the world are dying of hunger, lack of water and preventable and treatable diseases. It seems to me that our denomination has become insensitive to the needs of the world around us. Rather we have become too occupied with this debate on human sexuality and shamefully investing God’s resources into this debate.
Fortunately, dissolution is no more the issue before us. We are talking about separation. It seems to me that many of the critical issues cannot be resolved now until separation happens. For now, we can only guess that there will be two denominations that will emerge after the separation – The Renewal and Reformed Coalition and the Post Separation UMC. While I cannot say for sure what will happen in the New denomination that is being led by WCA, I can safely say that;
- General agencies, including Wespath, will now stay as part of the structure of the Post separation UMC.
- Africa will remain in the post separation UMC and Traditional
- The Centrist/Progressive coalition in the US will remain in the post separation UMC, and;
- Some traditionalists in the US will remain in the post separation UMC.
How this will work out for the post separation US church with centrists, progressives and traditionalists remains to be figured out. We need special prayers for God’s guidance to help us address this matter. What the Central Conferences and the Connectional Table are proposing is for each region – Africa, Europe, Philippines and the US to become a Regional Conference with each regional conference (hopefully) having its own book of discipline that will provide for dealing with contextual issues.”
In a recent session hosted by Stan Copeland at Lover’s Lane UMC in Dallas, Texas, Bishop Mande Muyombo (Northern Katanga, Tanzania) said this, “the challenge we have here in defining the word conservative, or more ‘traditionalist’ – we may have had here in the honeymoon talk that you heard – but the challenge that we have right now is that word is being interpreted for our people in the wrong way. In as much as I disagree with my LGBTQ person, I have to recognize his or her dignity. If I chase that individual out of the church, I’m wondering if I’m preaching the Gospel. The Gospel of love that Professor Empeche alluded to. And I think for the African church, that is the challenge we have. We cannot be perceived as people who come to oppress other people because of what we legislate. I think we have the challenge to reform ourselves and look into each other. If we are going to chase away people from the church, I am wondering…if we are still the church. So, again, I want to emphasize that point that the time has come for us to move into regional conferences, respect each other’s space, and give each other time to build relationships and talk to one another and be submissive and vulnerable to the work of the Holy Spirit.”
I hate to say this, but it’s been a while since a United Methodist Bishop has inspired me…and now I’m inspired by two! These Bishops have really challenged me. The African United Methodists are actually leading us forward. They are casting a vision to remain together as one church while allowing for regional, contextual flexibility on issues that are “non-essential” as relates to salvation. I didn’t think it was possible, but I am reminded that with God, all things are possible. They are teaching and leading us toward a new unity even in the midst of our disagreement on the issues confronting our church. They do not agree with same-sex marriage or LGBTQ ordination, but they can be a part of a church where that would occur in another context. They can also recognize and humbly ask for forgiveness for the harm done through previous UMC legislation. We may not all agree, but their words and actions may lead the United Methodist Church toward a powerful and transcendent understanding of unity taught by both Jesus and Paul.
I understand not everyone in Africa may agree with Bishops Yambasu and Muyombo, but I am grateful for two Bishops in our church that take the words from our Preamble seriously,”The church of Jesus Christ exists in and for the world, and its very dividedness is a hindrance to its mission in that world.”